扫描二维码，直接登录
题库 / OG2016-SC-138
Although she was considered among her contemporaries to be the better poet than her husband, later Elizabeth Barrett Browning was overshadowed by his success.
Although she was considered among her contemporaries to be the better poet than her husband, later Elizabeth Barrett Browning was overshadowed by his success.
Although Elizabeth Barrett Browning was considered among her contemporaries as a better poet than her husband, she was later overshadowed by his success.
Later overshadowed by the success of her husband, Elizabeth Barrett Browning's poetry had been considered among her contemporaries to be better than that of her husband.
Although Elizabeth Barrett Browning's success was later overshadowed by that of her husband, among her contemporaries she was considered the better poet.
Elizabeth Barrett Browning's poetry was considered among her contemporaries as better than her husband, but her success was later overshadowed by his.
题目分析：
略
选项分析：
A选项：当consider意为“看作（regard as）”时，只能用consider A B，而不能用consider A to be B。当consider意为“认为”时，只能用consider A to be B而不能用consider A B。看起来是在考查语法，实则不然，这背后是在考查考生的逻辑推理能力。在原理上近似于不定式和名词的区别。如果在consider的宾语和宾语的补足语间添加to be，则to be B就变成了不定式短语。我们知道，当consider表示“看作”时，其约束力较弱。看作是一种客观的说法，对“A是B”这个事件没有主观的控制。但当consider表示“认为，以为”时，显然，其约束力较强。因为“认为”这个动作有较深的主观色彩，其宾补部分必然要用不定式来表达。
本题中的consider是“看作”的意思，即，EBB被看作是她那个时代最好的诗人。
B选项：比较对象不对等。在逻辑上应该是Elizabeth Barrett Browning的“成功”被她丈夫的成功掩盖。
C选项：later overshadowed by the success of her husband是过去分词短语，做伴随状语，其主语为Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s poetry。但在逻辑上，被掩盖的应该是她的成功，而不是她的诗歌。
D选项：Correct. 本选项在逻辑和语法上均是正确的。
E选项：比较对象有误。不能用Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s poetry和her husband做比较。
解释的啥啊 你们确定通过上述A中解析考场上能做出来题吗？
附CD网解析：https://forum.chasedream.com/thread-1084061-1-1.html 别的老师也说了考的是比较对象
真实
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
A, same as above
两个问题：1.EB和success比较，错误。2."the better"只能用在句子前边已经出现了两个相比较的词，比如：Tuck and Yale are preeminent school, but TUCK is the better on MBA program. 在A中并没有先出现EB和her husband.
B, Although Elizabeth Barrett Brwoning was considered among her contemporaries as a better poet than her husband, she was later overshadowed by his success.
两个问题：1.EB和success比较，错误。2.“was considered among her contemporaries as”有歧义，一种意思是“EB被认为是她的同龄人中XXX"；另一种意思是“EB被她的同龄人认为是XXX"。
C, Later overshadowed by the success of her husband, Elizabeth Barrett Brwoning's poetry had been considered among her contemporaries to be better than that of her husband.
句首的modifier修饰了poetry,而不是EB,逻辑错误。
D, Although Elizabeth Barrett browning's success was later overshadowed by that of her husband, among her contemporaries she was considered the better poet.
EB's sucess与that（=sucess） of her husband比较，正确。
E, Elizabeth Barrett Browning's poetry was considered among her contemporaries as better than her husband, but her success was later overshadowed by his husband.
EB'S poetry和her husband比较，错误; success和his husband比较，错误。
关于这个题目我还有一点想法，idiom虽然可以作为判断的依据，但是并不是最优先级，我认为SC的判断的优先级应该是：句意>平行(比较也是平行的一种)>指代>modifier>idiom
这句话不太好区分consider是“看作”还是“认为”吧
没有选D的主要原因是语境。与A比较，A的主句强调EBB被她老公超越一事。D的主句反而强调了EBB是同时代最优者。
重要考点在overshadow的比较
为什么不能说EBB被她丈夫的success overshadowed呢？我觉得也可以
A和B: EBB应该被husband overshadowed 而不是his success，比较对象不平行。
C: EBB’poetry不能做later over shadowed by the success of her husband的主语。
E: EBB’s poetry 不能和her husband 对比，比较对象不平行。
C选项：later overshadowed by the success of her husband是过去分词短语，做伴随状语，其主语为Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s poetry。但在逻辑上，被掩盖的应该是她的成功，而不是她的诗歌。
关于C诗歌或者成功我更加认为是同一类东西，区分度没这么严格。
“诗歌 among 人” 这种说法我认为更加不合理。
A,
两个问题：1.EB和success比较，错误。2."the better"只能用在句子前边已经出现了两个相比较的词，比如：Tuck and Yale are preeminent school, but TUCK is the better on MBA program. 在A中并没有先出现EB和her husband.
B, Although Elizabeth Barrett Brwoning was considered among her contemporaries as a better poet than her husband, she was later overshadowed by his success.
两个问题：1.EB和success比较，错误。2.“was considered among her contemporaries as”有歧义，一种意思是“EB被认为是她的同龄人中XXX"；另一种意思是“EB被她的同龄人认为是XXX"。
C, Later overshadowed by the success of her husband, Elizabeth Barrett Brwoning's poetry had been considered among her contemporaries to be better than that of her husband.
句首的modifier修饰了poetry,而不是EB,逻辑错误。
D, Although Elizabeth Barrett browning's success was later overshadowed by that of her husband, among her contemporaries she was considered the better poet.
EB's sucess与that（=sucess） of her husband比较，正确。
E, Elizabeth Barrett Browning's poetry was considered among her contemporaries as better than her husband, but her success was later overshadowed by his husband.
EB'S poetry和her husband比较，错误; success和his husband比较，错误。
关于这个题目我还有一点想法，idiom虽然可以作为判断的依据，但是并不是最优先级，我认为SC的判断的优先级应该是：句意>平行(比较也是平行的一种)>指代>modifier>idiom
因为GMAC并没有给出idiom的正确清单，在不同的句子中有可能原来认为错误的idiom就正确，比如OG16里的这题，关于A选项的解释就没有说consider to be 是错误的，其他选项的解释里也没有说consider as是错误的，我记得manhattan上的说consider sth sth是正确用法，consider sth to be用法存疑，consider as是错误的，但是没有明确的证据能说明GMAC也这样看，或许下次的题目中又正确了呢。当然，这题如果用idiom可以迅速排出ABE,剩下CD，然后可以马上选出D，考场上可能也是挺好方法。
一个是the better的问题：只能用在两个人中间
再一个是success只能跟success比较，不能说人被success遮盖
比较对象问题，只有D比较对了
AB: E.B. was overshadowed by his success, 语义错误，人被成功盖过了。
C： overshadowed的主语是poetry，语义错误，诗被成功盖过了。
E：poetry was better than her husband，比较对象错误，应该用诗来跟诗做比较。
我个人觉得这题运用 句子准确性，精确性的考点上去看会更容易。在考场上 很难去做这么权威的 分析
A： OG 给的解释是，这里用错了 the better, a better sth than.. the better 不能再加 than 了 应该是 EB is the better poet 或者是 a better poet than his husband . 但我觉得 这题也可以直接去看他的 句意。 A 选项中.. the better poet than her husband， 后直接说 later EB was overshadowed. 在这里 就会给我一种疑问.. the better poet, why ? the better poet 完 怎么样？ 他没提. 直接跳到后面 overshadowed by his success 另外一个点上了. 在句意上给我一种不完整性
B： 同上
C： 还可以从 句意上去理解。最后一句 among her contemporaries to be better than that of her husband. 这里OG 给的解释是 这句话 他是把 EB 的 poetry 和 他丈夫的poetry 比， 但原文意思应该是要跟他的success 比. 我个人是觉得比较难理解. 观看这一句话在一分钟内 我怎么知道他是跟谁比。 所以这里的that 给我一种不确定性，不够好.
D： 第一个条件状语中的之代词that 很明显是对应 之前的success 没问题， she was considered the better poet. 我觉得在句意上很连贯 没问题
E；这个我觉得毕出老师分析的很对。比较对象错了 比较明显， poetry 直接跟husband 对， 应该改成 poetry and his husband's poetry
A：consider的约束力较弱，所以不能用To be.
B: 错选了B，我一开始认为是EBB这个人被他丈夫的成功Overshadowed (类似于人隐退了那种感觉...)看来出题人不是这么个意思。应该是丈夫的成功Overshadowed EBB的成功。
C：consider问题同A
D：EBB的成功被丈夫的成功Overshadowed。ok
E：better than比较对象不对，不能把EBB的诗歌和她的丈夫做比较，应该比较诗歌与诗歌或者人比人
Pronoun不能指代所有格中的名词，比如D选项中，因为只有Elizabeth‘s 出现，所以she是不能指代Elizabeth的。
但是her同样作为所有格是可以指代Elizabeth‘s 的，而不是指代Elizabeth。
注意：D选项中出现了代词指代A’B中的A的情况，首先本句中先出现了一个her，her是能指代形容性的所有格的，其次本句中只有EB能被指代，不存在歧义，所以可以用She指代EBB’success中的EBB
看作和认为不都是对的吗………………………………
人不能被success超过
the sentence misuses the location the better poet. It is acceptbale to say a better poet than but not the better poet than. If you have already mentioned two poets X and Y, and you want to say that X is better than Y, you can either say X is a better poet than Y or simply, X is the better poet.
idiom： consider A B, A be considered B
A：，当consider表示“看作”时，其约束力较弱。