In 1563, in Florence's Palazzo Vecchio, Giorgio Vasari built in front of an existing wall a new wall on which he painted a mural. Investigators recently discovered a gap between Vasari's wall and the original, large enough to have preserved anything painted on the original. Historians believe that Leonardo daVinci had painted, but left unfinished, a mural on the original wall; some historians had also believed that by 1563 the mural had been destroyed.However, it is known that in the late 1560s, when renovating another building, Santa Maria Novella, Vasari built a façade over its frescoes, and the frescoes were thereby preserved. Thus, Leonardo's Palazzo Vecchio mural probably still exists behind Vasari's wall.

Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?    


Leonardo rarely if ever destroyed artworks that he left unfinished.    

Vasari was likely unaware that the mural in the Palazzo Vecchio had willingly been abandoned by Leonardo.    

Vasari probably would not have built the Palazzo Vecchio wall with a gap behind it except to preserve something behind the new wall.    

Leonardo would probably have completed the Palazzo Vecchio mural if he had had the opportunity to do so.    

When Vasari preserved the frescoes of Santa Maria Novella he did so secretly.    

加入错题本 分享
纠错
考题讲解

情景：1563年在FPV这个地方 ，GV这个人在一个墙的前面新建了一个墙并且画了壁画。最近发现两墙之间的空隙足够保存后面那堵墙上的东西了。历史学家相信达芬奇在原来那堵墙上画了壁画但是没画完。但又有历史学家认为原墙上的壁画1563年前已经被毁了。然而，1560晚期，GV在SMN的建筑的frescoes上又建了一个façade，因此其壁画被保存下来。所以大家认为达芬奇的壁画还在。

推理：

（果）前提：两墙之间有缝隙

（因）结论：达芬奇的画还在


选项分析：

A选项：达芬奇很少会毁坏没画完的壁画：我们讨论的是“有缝隙的原因”是不是“画还在”，和达芬奇会不会毁坏没画完的画无关。

B选项：GV有可能没意识到达芬奇是有意放弃他作的壁画的：不管达芬奇是不是有意识放弃壁画、GV有没有意识到，我们讨论的是壁画有没有被保存下来这个结果。

C选项：正确。GV可能不会在墙之间留缝隙除非他想保护新墙后面的什么东西：直接解释了    GV留缝隙的原因，证明了达芬奇的画还在

D选项：达芬奇如果有机会的话会完成他的壁画的：我们讨论的是有没有保存下来，而不是有没有完成壁画。

E选项：GV是秘密保存SMN的壁画的：与是不是秘密保存无关。

展开显示

登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论

OG2022-CR