Were it not for the fusion-powered heat and radiation that rush from its core, instead its own weight would cause a star to collapse.
instead its own weight would cause a star to collapse
instead a star would have collapsed under its own weight
a star would have to be collapsing under its own weight
a star would collapse under its own weight
its own weight would have caused a star's collapse
题目分析:
略。
选项分析:
A选项:语法有误,虚拟语气句子,主句必须一开头就是主语,而不能是连词、副词,因此instead错误。
B选项:instead错误同选项(A)。
C选项:would have to be collapsing是很混乱的时态;would have to是不很肯定的语气,其表达的是have to do的内容只是一个假设,并不是真的“必须”,而have to表达的意思是,要做的事情非常重要,“必须”去做,前后矛盾。
D选项:Correct. 本选项在语法和逻辑上均是正确的。
E选项:名词短语a star’s collapse需改为不定式短语a star to collapse,这点考查了不定式和名词的区别,用之于本题,显然地,cause的约束力较强,身后应用不定式做宾语和宾语的补足语。
然后就会知道这是个虚拟语气/条件状语从句
A/B的Instead of碰上 if it were是赘余的
C/D成分没有差异,对比时态 C的正在进行时没有题目中没有依据
E 虽然毕老师的解释中说是不定式短语的问题,但是我一般看不出来这种问题。我认为如E所写,句中的it就无所指代了(GMAT一般不会去指代a star's collapse里面的star,我没见过这样指代对的)
要不是核聚变产生的热量和辐射从它的核心涌出,【一颗恒星】会在自身重量下坍塌
A. 前面it指代后面主句的主语,成了指代its own weight,错误;这样的虚拟语气句子, 主句必须一开头就 是主语,而不能是连词、副词,因此instead错误; its指代不清
B. Instead错误同A;本句子描述的是当下的一个假设情形下的一个假设结果,要用现在时态,用would have collapsed表示了“与过去相反(也就是表示过去没崩溃)”不对。
C. Would have to be collapsing是很混乱的时态; would have to是不很肯定的语气,其表达的是have to do 的内容只是一个假设,并不是真的“必须”,而have to表达的意思是,要做的事情非常重要,“必须” 去做
D. correct
E. it指代了its own weight,错误; its指代不清; would have caused错误同B。
然后就会知道这是个【虚拟语气/条件状语从句】!
A/B选项:instead a star would have collapsed under its own weight语法有误,虚拟语气句子,主句必须一开头就是主语,而不能是连词、副词,因此instead错误。
D选项:a star 【would】 collapse under its own weight正确
主句不能有instead,AB错误
C. would have to be 错误
E. would have done是“本可以...但没有“,是过去式,错误
后面一定要是个完整的句子,而且主句必须一开头就是主语,AB错
2.动词时态,CE的have肯定是错的。
3.句意推理,have caused a star's collapse,E的这个句意错了,是哪个星星的?不是他本身?E错
看到群友登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
A选项:语法有误,虚拟语气句子,主句必须一开头就是主语,而不能是连词、副词,因此instead错误。
C选项:would have to be collapsing是很混乱的时态;would have to是不很肯定的语气,其表达的是have to do的内容只是一个假设,并不是真的“必须”,而have to表达的意思是,要做的事情非常重要,“必须”去做,前后矛盾。
if 虚拟,then would do
if had done,then would have done
要用instead的话,改成:It's not A, but instead it's B
倒装+虚拟语气
it这里做形式主语,起强调作用。也可以是If not for the fusion-powered heat and radiation,……
A,if接then,instead错误
B,C,D,would have错误
if/then时态
主句从现(通常)
if did/were to,then would
if had done, then would have done
if should, then would
CE选项:时态有误
= If it were not / (had not been) for N
= Were it not for N / (Had it not been for N)
= Without N(介词只有without可表虚拟语气)
2. CD:成分一致的情况下才看时态,明显现在进行时不适用于此
重点:严谨逻辑的辨析
CD说的是,一个星星在这种重量下坍塌;而E说的是,重量造成了星星的坍塌;
此处有两点问题:1. cause应该是一件事情而不是一个东西;2. 重量不能构成造成星星坍塌的主要施动者,应该是在某种重量状况下坍塌。
在GMAT考试中,逻辑严谨的辨析非常重要,如果A能推出B,B能推出C,GMAT绝不接受A能推出C。
我觉得还可以理解为under weight 和 for radiation是形式上更并列。 把weight作为主语不妙登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
= If it were not / (had not been) for N
= Were it not for N / (Had it not been for N)
= Without N(介词只有without可表虚拟语气)
虚拟语气的时态:
时间 从句谓语形式 主句谓语形式
将来 动词过去式(be用were)
should + 动词原形
were to + 动词原形 would / should / might / could + 动词原形
现在 动词过去式(be 用 were) would / should / might / could + 动词原形
过去 had +动词过去分词 would / should / might / could have + 动词过去分词