For the last five years the Dutch economy has grown faster than Britain, France, or Germany, with the unemployment rate having remained well below that of the other three countries.
Britain, France, or Germany, with the unemployment rate having remained
have those of Britain, France, or Germany, and the unemployment rate remaining
have Britain, France, and Germany, and the unemployment rate has remained
the economy of Britain, France, and Germany, with the unemployment rate that has remained
the economies of Britain, France, and Germany, and the unemployment rate has remained
D:economy显得 Britain, France, and Germany共有一个,所以要改成economies。
with。。。无法理解。。
感谢由 百香果蜂蜜茶 对此题目的解答所做出的贡献。
“(A) 比较对象不对等,将经济和国家进行比较;with的逻辑主语是Dutch economy,错误;现在完成时的进行时态having remained不可以做限定性修饰,错误。
(B) those没有所指代的词;and后不是一个整句,没有谓语动词。
(C) 比较对象不对等,将经济和国家进行比较。
(D) with的逻辑主语是Dutch economy,错误。”
(1) 比较的对象 Dutch economy 与the economies of Britain, France, and Germany.
(2) with 引导的状语修饰 是修饰主句的动作和状态的, 所以在这里就是在说the unemployment rate that has remained 只修饰了 dutch economy,与作者想要表达的意思不一致。
D.选项有两个问题:1.economy在此处应该指3个国家的经济,应该用economies,而不是共用1个经济,所以要用复数
2.with unemployment rate[that has...],介词短语作状语,翻译过来是:带着失业率,荷兰经济..;实际上二者并没有修饰关系,应该用平行
D.with放句尾時會修飾前一句的V或O,因此在此處不恰當
c, have economics of ... 就是对的了,这里的economics没了之后,比较的对象不对
with短语通常是状语,状语嘛,是描述主句中的动作的特征和特点的。显然,这里经济增长快慢显然不能被rate来描述。
D选项的with为什么不行呢,觉得低失业率伴随快速增长的经济挺合适的啊?
I think 'with' is fine. It is absolute construction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_construction
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
一定要去注意economy是有单复数的...
D选项:two big reasons
1) "the economy of Britain, France, and Germany"
--> illogically implies that these three countries share only one economy. (note that the correct answer correctly uses the plural "economies" to refer to the existence of three different economies.)
2) "with the unemployment rate that has remained"
--> implies, without justification, that the dutch economy is the ONLY economy with an unemployment rate that has satisfied this criterion.
不太懂为什么 d选项with的逻辑主语是dutch economy 就是错的
我觉得不能用economy来排除啊,之前有做过一道题 A mixture of poems and short fiction, Jean Toomer's Cane has been called one of the three best novels ever written by a Black American—the others being Richard Wright's Native Son and Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man. 里面就是用的a Black American
Ron:
1) "the economy of Britain, France, and Germany"
--> illogically implies that these three countries share only one economy. (note that the correct answer correctly uses the plural "economies" to refer to the existence of three different economies.)
2) "with the unemployment rate that has remained"
--> implies, without justification, that the dutch economy is the ONLY economy with an unemployment rate that has satisfied this criterion.
C为什么不对呢?倒装之后就等于 D has grown faster than Britain, France, and Germany have (grown)...??完全懵逼啊
比较对象错了。
啊对!!跳出来看就是这样!!谢谢你呀!!!!
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
with不能修饰前句...
请问老师with结构如何解释进行排除呢?
with短语通常是状语,状语嘛,是描述主句中的动作的特征和特点的。显然,这里经济增长快慢显然不能被rate来描述。
伴随着较低的失业率Dutch的经济快速增长。这做状语好像很合适啊
失业率和经济增长,我也举得蛮合适的诶
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
选项A 比较对象不等,把经济与国家进行比较,with的主语是dutch economy 现在完成进行时,不可以做限制性修饰
选项B those没有所指代的词and后面不是一个句子
c比较对象不等
d后半句with的逻辑主语是dutch economy