In the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, many Western Pueblo settlements in what is now the southwestern UnitedStates may have possessed distinctly hierarchical organizational structures. These communities' agricultural systems—which were "intensive" in the use of labor rather than "extensive" in area—may have given rise to political leadership that managed both labor and food resources. That formal management of food resources was needed is suggested by the large size of storage spaces located around some communal Great Kivas (underground ceremonial chambers). Though no direct evidence exists that such spaces were used to store food, Western Pueblo communities lacking sufficient arable land to support their populations could have preserved the necessary extra food, including imported foodstuffs, in such apparently communal spaces.
Moreover, evidence of specialization in producing raw materials and in manufacturing ceramics and textiles indicates differentiation of labor within and between communities. The organizational and managerial demands of such specialization strengthen the possibility that a decision-making elite existed, an elite whose control over labor, the use of community surpluses, and the acquisition of imported goods would have led to a concentration of economic resources in their own hands. Evidence for differential distribution of wealth is found in burials of the period: some include large quantities of pottery, jewelry, and other artifacts, whereas others from the same sites lack any such materials.
Which of the following, if true, would most clearly undermine the author's statement in the last sentence of the passage regarding the distribution of wealth in Western Pueblo settlements?
Only community members of exceptional wealth are likely to have been buried with their personal possessions.
Members of communities with extensive agricultural systems are usually buried without personal possessions.
Most artifacts found in burial sites were manufactured locally rather than imported from other communities.
Burial artifacts are often ritual objects associated with religious practices rather than being the deceased's personal possessions.
The quality of burial artifacts varies depending on the site with which they are associated.
此讲解的内容由AI生成,还未经人工审阅,仅供参考。
正确答案是 D。
选择此选项的原因是,作者在最后一句话中提到了墓地中的遗物可能表明财富的差异分布。这个选项表明,墓地中的艺术品很可能是宗教仪式上使用的,而不是去世者的私人财物,从而削弱了作者的说法,也就是财富是不同的。
B选项,文章第一段话“These communities\' agricultural systems-which were \"intensive\" in the use of labor rather than \"extensive\" in area-may have given rise to polit- ical leadership that managed both labor and food resources. ”说明了这是个intensive agricultural systems,因此后面的内容都和extensive无关
文章中的讨论对象These communities限制为intensive" in the use of labor,与extensive agricultural systems无关!!!
讨论的是intensive不是extensive!
choice a, 只有非常富裕的成员才有可能带着个人财产下葬。strengthen the conclusion
choice b, communities with extensive agricultural systems- 文章通篇的scope都限定在intensive agriculture system
choice d, 被埋葬的物品一般是宗教用途,而不是亡者的个人财产。correct
B错在文章说的是intensive system而不是extensive system,要注意,D可以直接削弱文章的观点即财富属于个人物品,说的是不属于个人,所以D正确。
B错在文章说的是intensive system而不是extensive system,要注意,D可以直接削弱文章的观点即财富属于个人物品,说的是不属于个人,所以D正确。