For similar cars and comparable drivers, automobile insurance for collision damage has always cost more in Greatport than in Fairmont. Police studies, however, show that cars owned by Greatport residents are, on average, slightly less likely to be involved in a collision than cars in Fairmont. Clearly, therefore, insurance companies are making a greater profit on collision-damage insurance in Greatport than in Fairmont.

In evaluating the argument, it would be most useful to compare


the level of traffic congestion in Greatport with the level of traffic congestion in Fairmont

the cost of repairing collision damage in Greatport with the cost of repairing collision damage in Fairmont

the rates Greatport residents pay for other forms of insurance with the rates paid for similar insurance by residents of Fairmont

the condition of Greatport's roads and streets with the condition of Fairmont's roads and streets

the cost of collision-damage insurance in Greatport and Fairmont with that in other cities

加入错题本 分享
纠错
考题讲解

情景：对于相同的车和司机，保险公司在Greatport的车祸保险费高于Fairmont。然而，研究表明，Greatport的车比Fairmont的车更不容易发生事故。因此，保险公司在汽车险上所赚的钱，Greatport多于Fairmont。

推理：由于前提和结论讲的是不同的事情，并且保险公司要先理赔，才能盈利，所以本题是因果推理。
顺序的因果逻辑：因为保险公司在Greatport的车祸保险费高于Fairmont，且Greatport的车比Fairmont的车更不容易发生事故，所以保险公司在汽车险上所赚的钱，Greatport多于Fairmont
（因）前提：保险公司在Greatport的车祸保险费高于Fairmont，且Greatport的车比Fairmont的车更不容易发生事故
（果）结论：保险公司在汽车险上所赚的钱，Greatport多于Fairmont

选题方式：因果推理只有一个评估方向，简而言之，即，反驳推理文段中的结论。

选项分析：

A选项：Greatport和Fairmont两地的交通拥挤度相比。交通拥挤度和保险公司利润无关。

B选项：Correct. Greatport和Fairmont两地的损失修补费相比。显然地，损失修补费将会决定保险公司的成本，继而决定利润。

C选项：Greatport和Fairmont两地居民买其他险种的比例相比。居民保险的数量和保险公司利润无关。

D选项：Greatport和Fairmont两地的路况相比。路况好坏，只要不涉及理赔，就和保险公司利润无关。

E选项：Greatport和Fairmont两地跟其它地方的车祸保险费相比。其它地域的保险和这两地保险公司的利润无关。

展开显示

登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论

OG2015-CR
考点