Scientists generally credit violent collisions between tectonic plates, the mobilefragments of Earth's rocky outer shell, with sculpting the planet's surface, as, for example, when what is now the Indian subcontinent collided with Asia, producing the Himalayan Mountains. However, plate tectonics cannot fully explain certain massive surface features, such as the "superswell" of southern Africa, a vast plateau over 1,000 miles across and nearly a mile high. Geologic evidence shows that southern African has been slowly rising for the past 100 million years, yet it has not experienced a tectonic collision for nearly 400 million years. The explanation may be in Earth's mantle, the layer of rock underlying the tectonic plates and extending down over 1,800 miles to the outer edge of Earth's iron core.
Since the early twentieth century, geophysicists have understood that the mantle churns and roils like a thick soup. The relative low density of the hottest rock makes that material buoyant, so it slowly ascends, while cooler, denser rock sinks until heat escaping the molten core warms it enough to make it rise again. While this process of convection was known to enable the horizontal movement of tectonic plates, until recently geophysicists were skeptical of its ability to lift or lower the planet's surface vertically. However, recent technological advances have allowed geophysicists to make three-dimensional "snapshots" of the mantle by measuring vibrations, or seismic waves, set in motion by earthquakes originating in the planet's outer shell and recording the time it takes for them to travel from an earthquake's epicenter to a particular recording station at the surface. Because geophysicists know that seismic waves become sluggish in hot, low-density rock, and speed up in colder, denser regions, they can now infer the temperatures and den- sities in a given segment of the interior. By compiling a map of seismic velocities from thousands of earthquakes across the globe, they can also begin to map temperatures and densities throughout the mantle. These methods have revealed some unexpectedly immense for- mations in the deepest parts of the mantle; the largest of these is a buoyant mass of hot rock directly below Africa's southern tip. Dispelling researchers' initial doubts, computer models have confirmed that this formation is buoyant enough to rise slowly within the mantle and strong enough to push Africa upward as it rises.
According to the passage, the computer models(highlight text) referred to have had which of the following effects?
They have confirmed researchers' doubts regarding the theory that convection within the mantle can lift or lower Earth's surface vertically.
They have cast doubt on the validity of plate-tectonics theory as an explanation for the sculpting of Earth's mountain ranges.
They have proved geophysicists' theory that the behavior of seismic waves in Earth's mantle is related to the temperature of the rock through which they are traveling.
They have convinced formerly skeptical researchers that rock formations deep in Earth's mantle below southern Africa could have created the superswell.
They have confirmed researchers' speculation that masses of hot rock are buoyant enough to rise to the upper part of Earth's mantle.
此讲解的内容由AI生成,还未经人工审阅,仅供参考。
正确答案是D。之所以选择D,是因为文章提到,最近的技术进步让地球物理学家可以通过测量由地球外壳中的地震产生的震动或地震波,来对地幔进行三维快照,并且根据地震波变慢的热低密度岩石和加速的冷高密度岩石获得其温度和密度。电脑模型证明了研究人员最初的怀疑,即非洲南部以下的熔岩内的岩石形成物足够浮力上升到地球的上部地幔中,从而产生了超级涌升层(superswell)。
Cast doubt 是提出怀疑 以为是解决怀疑 晕了
initial doubt 不就是superswell怎么出现的吗!
定位doubt到原文里去
本题就是非常经典的doing,svo,问作用的类型。这里的作用,其实就是看doing咯。
因为文章第一段的doubt是convection(空气对流产生的反复加热过程,为什么说反复是因为文章用到了rise again,所以这应该是加热上升-遇冷下降-再次加热上升,这样一个过程)可以使得mass加热然后上升,从而改变地貌;而文章第二段的解释是:在地幔的最深处有很大的bouyant material,这些material可以一直缓慢地上升,这就不是convection这样一个动作了。
譬如convection是两个板块一上一下,这样蹭出来的一个山,但第二段讲的这个就像是一个板块的能量很足,他就一直往上升,变成了一个高地,这是两个不同的地貌形成逻辑,所以之前skeptical也被推翻了,D是对的。
researchers' speculation is about the convection, not the masses of hot rock.
最后得出的结论是在地幔处(板块之下)有很多的formation,才导致了地表的变化,这个是unexpectedly的,所以并没有证实任何人的猜想,只是消除了疑虑,选D(一个新的理论)
dispelling the initial doubt-> convince the formerly skeptical researchers...
错选了E……
Dispelling researchers' initial doubts, computer models have confirmed that this formation is buoyant enough to rise slowly within the mantle and strong enough to push Africa upward as it rises.
电脑模型驱散了研究人员最初的疑惑。这个doubt定位-until recently geophysicists were skeptical of its ability to lift or lower the planet's surface vertically研究人员怀疑mantle将地球表面垂直移动的能力
dispel:vt. 驱散,驱逐;消除(烦恼等)
Dispelling researchers' initial doubts, 之前的doubt是were skeptical of its ability to lift or lower the planet's surface vertically.
E选项原文是push Africa upward 而不是 upper part of Earth's mantle
这段跨度也有点大...首先computer model dispelling previous doubt regarding Africa's southern tip. 这里得回到第一段,scientist对superswell" of southern Africa的doubt
为什么A错了?
是不是confirm和原文的dispelling不能混为一谈哦
那D用的不也是convince咩
可是A是confirm了他们的doubt D是让他们信服了后面那个事实 解决了doubt 好像还是不一样滴
你在说什么歪理哦
不服打架
因为文章第一段的doubt是convection(空气对流产生的反复加热过程,为什么说反复是因为文章用到了rise again,所以这应该是加热上升-遇冷下降-再次加热上升,这样一个过程)可以使得mass加热然后上升,从而改变地貌;而文章第二段的解释是:在地幔的最深处有很大的bouyant material,这些material可以一直缓慢地上升,这就不是convection这样一个动作了。
譬如convection是两个板块一上一下,这样蹭出来的一个山,但第二段讲的这个就像是一个板块的能量很足,他就一直往上升,变成了一个高地,这是两个不同的地貌形成逻辑,所以之前skeptical也被推翻了,D是对的。
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
细节题,These methods have revealed some unexpectedly immense for- mations in the deepest parts of the mantle; the largest of these is a buoyant mass of hot rock directly below Africa's southern tip.....this formation is buoyant enough to rise slowly within the mantle and strong enough to push Africa upward as it rises. 同义改写
Dispelling researchers' initial doubts, 之前的doubt是were skeptical of its ability to lift or lower the planet's surface vertically.
E选项原文是push Africa upward 而不是 upper part of Earth's mantle
现象解释+新老观念对比 即 观点A 然而 观点B。
第一段: 现象:板块运动形成山 ➡️反例:有些就不是 怀疑是mantle 行为导致。
第二段:传统观点: 认为 mantle只能水平影响山 ➡️ 新观点:通过地震实验得知也可以竖直影响山。
注意:体会confirm和convince
confirm是证实了科学家们的推测
但是文章中说的是dispel了科学家们的doubts,也就是说驱散了他们的怀疑,使他们信服
差点错选E...
effect 类似于作用 先找前后文有的说法,原词重现概率较大,如果没有再看选项
dispelling researchers' initial doubts, dispel 驱散
本题就是非常经典的doing,svo,问作用的类型。这里的作用,其实就是看doing咯。
Dispelling 驱散