Researchers studying how genes control animal behavior have had to deal with many uncertainties. Inthe first place, most behaviors are governed by more than one gene, and until recently geneticists had no method for identifying the multiple genes involved. In addition, even when a single gene is found to control a behavior, researchers in different fields do not necessarily agree that it is a "behavioral gene." Neuroscientists, whose interest in genetic research is to understand the nervous system (which generates behavior), define the term broadly. But ethologists—specialists in animal behavior—are interested in evolution, so they define the term narrowly. They insist that mutations in a behavioral gene must alter a specific normal behavior and not merely make the organism ill, so that the genetically induced behavioral change will provide variation that natural selection can act upon, possibly leading to the evolution of a new species. For example, in the fruit fly, researchers have identified the gene Shaker, mutations in which cause flies to shake violently under anesthesia. Since shaking is not healthy, ethologists do not consider Shaker a behavioral gene. In contrast, ethologists do consider the gene period (per), which controls the fruit fly's circadian (24-hour) rhythm, a behavioral gene because files with mutated per genes are healthy; they simply have different rhythms.
It can be inferred from the passage that which of the following, if true, would be most likely to influence ethologists' opinions about whether a particular gene in a species is a behavioral gene?
The gene is found only in that species.
The gene is extremely difficult to identify.
The only effect of mutations in the gene is to make the organism ill.
Neuroscientists consider the gene to be a behavioral gene.
Geneticists consider the gene to be a behavioral gene.
此讲解的内容由AI生成,还未经人工审阅,仅供参考。
答案是 D。解释:从文章中可以看出,由于神经科学家和行为专家对行为基因的定义不同,如果神经学家把某种基因定义为行为基因,那么行为专家很可能也会把这个基因定义为行为基因。所以,选择 D 是正确的答案,因为如果神经学家把基因定义为行为基因,那么行为专家也可能会把这种基因定义为行为基因。
whether 可以回答是和否!!!c选项:the only effect is to make the organism ill 即可以判断这一定不是behavioral gene。
原文They insist that mutations in a behavioral gene must alter a specific normal behavior and not merely make the organism ill。即必须同时满足2点:1)改变特定的正常行为。2)不至于导致器官病变。2个条件中的任意一个不满足就可以判断
如果对C的回答是yes,也就是说导致了器官病变,那就可以判断他不是behavioral gene了
题目的意思是可以成为判断依据即出现这个指标就可以判断,而不是说满足这个条件就是
They insist that mutations in a behavioral gene must alter a specific normal behavior and not merely make the organism ill,
whether 可以回答是和否!!!c选项:the only effect is to make the organism ill 即可以判断这一定不是behavioral gene。
题目理解错了,以为要选的是可以判断它是行为基因的一项~
哪一句话对e的观点有影响,c和原文说的是反的,所以选c,没看清,没注意merely,,
题目理解错了。。。
直接细节题:They insist that mutations in a behavioral gene must alter a specific normal behavior and not merely make the organism ill。即必须同时满足2点:1)改变特定的正常行为。2)不至于导致器官病变。2个条件中的任意一个不满足就可以判断
这道题有点意思,看到C的时候就一下排除了,因为题目中说的是not only ill,但是!题目说的是whether E可以确定这是不是一个behavioural gene?C的答案是否定的,也就是说E可以判断,但是判断的结果是否定的,所以C是对的。ABDE都不能确定,答案选C。
有点数学数据充分性问题的意思。
这道题有点意思,看到C的时候就一下排除了,因为题目中说的是not only ill,但是!题目说的是whether E可以确定这是不是一个behavioural gene?C的答案是否定的,也就是说E可以判断,但是判断的结果是否定的,所以C是对的。ABDE都不能确定,答案选C。
whether是否,判断为是和判断为否都可以