In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation as did its return in 1910–1911.
did its return in 1910–1911
had its 1910–1911 return
in its return of 1910–1911
its return of 1910–1911 did
its return in 1910–1911
题目分析:
本题比较简单。我们需要知道对比的两者为“两个时间发生的情况”。本句的意思是:“历史上没有哪次哈雷彗星回归造成了跟1910-1911回归的这样的世界性范围的轰动。”本题比较难的地方是看出一个倒装,即,In no other historical sighting这个表否定的状语位于句首引起了整个句子的倒装。由此可知,(A)(B)(D)(E)中的对比对象均是不正确的,答案为(C)。
选项分析:
略
倒装,原句等同于Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation In no other historical sighting as in its return in 1910–1911
a worldwide sensation In no other historical sighting和 a worldwide sensation in its return in 1910–1911对比平行,可以省略 a worldwide sensation
经典比较、省略、倒装、强调句
首先句子是否定倒装的句,用来强调没有哪个可以跟这个比。
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation
还原后应该是Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting...
as后面应该是(Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation) in its return of 1910–1911
由于as后面的前半大部分都是重复的,因此可以被省略掉
再回看其他选项有什么问题:
A.did its return in 1910–1911=its return cuase such a worldwide sensation...主语变成了its return而不是comet,跟前面不平行。
B.had its 1910–1911 return。这个时态就是错的,没有时间参考对象,另外主语也不平行
D和E都跟A同理。
这个题必须要注意是一个倒装句,而且是强调句,找准主语是谁,比较的是什么东西才行。
原句:H caused a sensation in no time than…后面比较的应该是相同主体(H)
A: H caused a sensation in no time than its return did in 1910 比较主体变成了H vs return
B: H caused a sensation in no time than its return had 比较主体变成了H vs return
C: H caused a sensation in no time than in its return of 1910
E: H caused a sensation in no time than its return in 1910 比较主体变成了H vs return
这个题唯一的主语是comet,ABD都是彗星与return在比较
Halley 's comet did cause such a worlwide sensation in no other historical sighting as (it did) in its return of 1910-1911
比較用法的兩大兩小原則:
第一大:比較用片語的適當性
-普通比較(more 配 than, as配as...)
-特殊比較(compared to/with , as, like/unlike...)
第二大:可比性(平行對稱)
-人比人、物比物、懶x不能比雞腿
第一小:排除自己原則
-Taipei 101 was once taller than "any other" buildings in the world.
第二小:指明要比誰(是否補出助動詞)
S....+比較用法....+O...than/as
若與主詞相比要補出助動詞。
引用,经典比较、省略、倒装、强调句
首先句子是否定倒装的句,用来强调没有哪个可以跟这个比。
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation
还原后应该是Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting...
as后面应该是(Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation) in its return of 1910–1911
由于as后面的前半大部分都是重复的,因此可以被省略掉
再回看其他选项有什么问题:
A.did its return in 1910–1911=its return cuase such a worldwide sensation...主语变成了its return而不是comet,跟前面不平行。
B.had its 1910–1911 return。这个时态就是错的,没有时间参考对象,另外主语也不平行
D和E都跟A同理。
这个题必须要注意是一个倒装句,而且是强调句,找准主语是谁,比较的是什么东西才行。
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation as in its return of 1910–1911.
历史上没有哪次哈雷彗星回归造成了跟1910-1911回归的这样的世界性范围的轰动。
an event of + 年份,正确表达
C. (√)状语对比
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation
还原后应该是Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting...
as后面应该是(Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation) in its return of 1910–1911
由于as后面的前半大部分都是重复的,因此可以被省略掉
its return of 1910-1911:它在1910-1911的回归,介词用of很常见,当然用in也可以
A. 比较双方不对等: HC和its return
B. 比较双方不对等: HC和its return; 助动词had错误,要用一般过去时
D. 比较双方不对等: HC和its return
E. 比较对象不对等:介词短语In no other historical sighting和名词短语its return in 1910–1911对比
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation as in its return of 1910–1911
Halley's comet cause such //a worldwide sensation 【in no other historical sighting】 as 【in its return of 1910–1911】//
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation 变换倒装得到:
Halley's comet did not cause such a worldwide sensation in other historical sighting (as XXXX)
括号中可以的内容有:
(it did) in its return of 1901-1911 这里的关键是 如果选项中存在了 its return 那起那面必定应该有个介词In
或者去掉return: (it did) in 1901-1911 也是可以的
A/D都错在将it's return 与 Halley‘s comet作比较
重点是要找到比较的两个主语:前面是什么,后面是什么
倒装,比较的是In no other historical sighting与in its return of 1910–1911
两个事件比较为什么要主语相同? i ate more pizza than he did, 我和他吃进行比较,没什么不可以。 你应该说的是:默认是同一个事件的时间比较,a今天做什么,明天做什么;肯定得是同一个主语,不然无法比较。但默认就是比较一个事件发生的不同时间并不是正确的解题方式。两个事件引起的不同轰动程度比较也是可以的,只是需要排除这个说法给出的选项用法不对。
为什么第二种说法不对呢?假如句子给出了2次事件造成的程度区别,例如几倍不同,则必须使用did,因为不能直接把比较的程度区别给省略了。也因为所有选项都直接省略了程度的区别,添加了时间的区别,则只能理解为比较的相同事件的时间区别。也因此主语应该相同,因为比较的是同一个事件的不同时间,不同事件的不同时间没法比较。与此同时,既然事件相同,则相同的事件部分全部可以省略,仅仅保留不同时间的比较就可以。
比较中什么都可以比较:时间可以比,程度可以比,地点也可比,动作也可比,主语也可比,etc。 正常都是容易看出比较的一个内容,也因而如果同时比较两个内容,则逻辑上是错误的,同样考察过。这个题目的难度在于,本题除了时间不同外,还添加的程度的区别,可想而知不同年代造成的轰动必然不同。所以逻辑上到底是比较时间还是程度成为了一个考点,考生需要通过选项排除对于程度的比较。并且句子给了一些提示,这也是为什么将时间部分进行倒桩,就是在提示进行时间比较,而不是程度比较。
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
comet cause such (senstation in no other historical sighting) as (sensation in its return in 1910)
Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting as in its return of 1910–1911.
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation as
倒装句,还原为: Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting as。。。
所以划线部分应该要和 in no other historical sighting 平行,是两个时间的比较。
1) as 说明是对比,要关注平行,in no other historical sighting与in 1910-1911不平行 (Ron)
2) 去掉状语后的句子是 did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation
知识点:比较,平行
注意such as 指 例如,譬如 (=for example)后面可加名词或短语。
such...as...单独两个词,中间和as后组成比较,相似的两个,像…这种的,像…那样的。
而e选项则是因为又可能省略了did又可能省略了in而可能有错误
remember that you're going to have to use MEANING to figure out what should be compared.
in this sentence, the non-underlined part contains the following elements:
* the comet DID cause a sensation
* IN no other sighting
so ... if you had "[some other sighting] DID", or "IN [something else that caused a sensation]", then that would be an error -- not necessarily a grammar error, but a meaning error because it'd be nonsense.
Halley 's comet did cause such a worlwide sensation in no other historical sighting as (it did) in its return of 1910-1911
比較用法的兩大兩小原則:
第一大:比較用片語的適當性
-普通比較(more 配 than, as配as...)
-特殊比較(compared to/with , as, like/unlike...)
,
第一小:排除自己原則
-Taipei 101 was once taller than "any other" buildings in the world.
比较的是其他次的回归与1910的回归,用这两个比
开头的In no other historical sighting是倒装,后面也用倒装