扫描二维码，直接登录
题库 / Prep2008E1-SC-245
In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation as did its return in 1910–1911.
did its return in 1910–1911
had its 1910–1911 return
in its return of 1910–1911
its return of 1910–1911 did
its return in 1910–1911
题目分析：
本题比较简单。我们需要知道对比的两者为“两个时间发生的情况”。本句的意思是：“历史上没有哪次哈雷彗星回归造成了跟1910-1911回归的这样的世界性范围的轰动。”本题比较难的地方是看出一个倒装，即，In no other historical sighting这个表否定的状语位于句首引起了整个句子的倒装。由此可知，(A)(B)(D)(E)中的对比对象均是不正确的，答案为(C)。
选项分析：
略
Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation In no other historical sighting as in its return in 1910–1911
=Halley's comet doesn't cause such a worldwide sensation In any other historical sighting as in its return in 1910–1911。
其实是一个not such/as的比较结构，因为前面的比较对象带了比较的范围，所以后面的被比较对象可以省略，只保留范围状语。
这个题唯一的主语是comet，ABD都是彗星与return在比较
只要用its return，都会产生“彗星和彗星的轨迹”进行对比的歧义
on the other hand, if you saw "IN [some other sighting]", or [something else that caused a sensation] DID", then that would create a valid comparison.
this, by the way, is the reason why choices (a) and (d) are wrong. they aren't grammatical errors; they just set the wrong things up to be compared.
remember that you're going to have to use MEANING to figure out what should be compared.
in this sentence, the non-underlined part contains the following elements:
* the comet DID cause a sensation
* IN no other sighting
so ... if you had "[some other sighting] DID", or "IN [something else that caused a sensation]", then that would be an error -- not necessarily a grammar error, but a meaning error because it'd be nonsense.
m
Halley 's comet did cause such a worlwide sensation in no other historical sighting as (it did) in its return of 1910-1911
比較用法的兩大兩小原則：
第一大：比較用片語的適當性
-普通比較(more 配 than, as配as...)
-特殊比較(compared to/with , as, like/unlike...)
第二大：可比性(平行對稱)
-人比人、物比物、懶x不能比雞腿
第一小：排除自己原則
-Taipei 101 was once taller than "any other" buildings in the world.
第二小：指明要比誰(是否補出助動詞)
S....+比較用法....+O...than/as
若與主詞相比要補出助動詞。
Hi Frank, 关于第二小，有例句解释一下吗？Thanks!!
第二小：指明要比誰(是否補出助動詞)
S....+比較用法....+O...than/as
若與主詞相比要補出助動詞。
Hi 第二小 指的是: 考SC句子的比較,容易省略重複名詞或助動詞的現象!
因此,SC句子的省略或是需不需要補足缺少的元素 通常 就是一個重要考點!
貼上影片說明連結:https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=569&v=OWz_B6yBS20
舉例:
1.I saw more Chinese than I saw Americans.
我看到的中國人比看到的美國人多
2.I saw more Chinese than Americans saw Chinese.
我看到的中國人多過美國人所看到的中國人
接下來,省略重複用字!求精簡
1.I saw more Chinese than Americans.
2.I saw more Chinese than Americans
結果發現儘管原句意思是不同的,但經過省略後句型卻一模一樣!!!那讀者就會誤解!
那此時,就要補上did,使than的前後比較平行
讀者便知道前後在比較主語,那語意上就不會誤解!
2. I saw more Chinese than American did.
Thanks so much, Frank!!! Btw，可以加你微信吗？可以交流一下，如果你未来需要FMCG或者ecom的perspective，我也可以share给你。
這兩題OG-2020 考點有包含比較+省略考點的題目:
OG2020-SC-800 正確選項-補出 they are ,才能跟前面的主語互相比較,不然會比到最近名詞speed
OG2020-SC-836 正確選項-補出hey did为“they evolved”的省略，they指代“linking arrangements between secondary schools and the workplace ”。
如果沒有補出they did 會直接跟正前方US比, 但實際我們想要比較的是:不同國家的linking arrangements 會有不同的evolved
不客氣 !! 可以加~
哈哈哈，那你得告诉我你的微信是？~~
看頭像~~~哈
试了wxid_18sefau06wms22，18sefau06wms22，180622，sefauwms，wxid_sefauwms都不没有找到相关用户~😂 所以我把我的头像名称改成微信账号了，你加我吧，哈哈
有找到 發邀請囉! (((o(*ﾟ▽ﾟ*)o)))
你俩最后在一起了吗
啊哈哈哈哈哈啊哈哈吃瓜
哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈
哈哈哈哈哈哈
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
A. 比较双方不对等：HC和its return
还原倒装发现平行结构
Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation In no other historical sighting as .......
还原倒装： Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting as in its returning of 1910-1911
个人觉得a错误的原因在于its return 不对 因为句子前后主语都因该是Halley's comet，不能是its return
C倒装：
Halley 's comet did cause such a worlwide sensation in no other historical sighting as (it did) in its return of 1910-1911
还原倒装： Halley's comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting as in its returning of 1910-1911
我们需要知道对比的两者为“两个时间发生的情况”。本句的意思是：“历史上没有哪次哈雷彗星回归造成了跟1910-1911回归的这样的世界性范围的轰动。”
比较主谓 共用一个主语 比较状语
调整结构 补全句子
784
*no other已经表明了它比的是 historical sighting
虽然做了很多遍这个题 但是感觉考场上碰到类似的依然会选错...
比较对象为in no other historical sighting和in its return of 1910–1911