In the seventh century B.C., the Roman alphabet was adapted from the Etruscan alphabet, which in turn had been adapted in the previous century from a western Greek alphabet, which itself had been adapted earlier in the same century from the Phoenician alphabet.
which itself had been adapted earlier
adapting itself earlier
itself being adapted earlier
having been earlier adapted itself
earlier itself having been adapted
题目分析:
本题中出现了反身代词itself,这种代词在GMAT考试中远不如普通代词(it、they等)常见,考生们需要从五个选项中注意理解反身代词的用法。
选项分析:
A选项:Correct. 本选项在逻辑和语法上均是正确的。本选项是定语从句,which后的itself是反身代词,此处做主语的同位语(先行词在该定语从句中充当主语)。
B选项:本选项的adapting是现在分词,做定语修饰a western Greek alphabet。这一点本身没有问题,但是,现在分词表示其同其逻辑主语的关系是主动关系,即,a western Greek alphabet主动的改编(adapt)了自己(此时,反身代词itself做adapt的宾语)。在逻辑上,只能是a western Greek alphabet被改编(adapt),而不能主动发出改编这个动作。
C选项:本选项是一个独立主格结构,但是在语法上不正确。因为,反身代词不能独立作主语,只能做主语的同位语。
D选项:having been earlier adapted itself中的itself位置不正确。同位语需要紧贴着先行词,放置在其身后。
E选项:本选项是独立主格结构,错误同(C)。
E. earlier應修飾in the same century,不應放前面修飾itself
回复所有人:解析已更新。
这道题想表达的是:GA来自于PA,所以A选项的which就近修饰GA正确/BCDE选项为:,ing形式,修饰前面的句子,不好。
对啦
A ;
B\C\D\E adapt,若为伴随状语,则逻辑主语和其主句主语一致,错;若为定语,考虑外延和内涵,adapt在定语部分,Greek alphabet 的adapt发生在Etruscan的adapt之后,不能用动名词;
earlier修饰in the century,和having been不重复。
但同问, 划线 部分应该比主句发生的早啊!不然主句主语怎么adapt from它。
在本选项中,显然地,主句the Etruscan alphabet in turn had been adapted in the previous century是先发生的,然后a western Greek alphabet才会被改编,因此,本选项不能用现在分词短语来修饰a western Greek alphabet。 我也觉得讲反了,应该是western 先改编啊,
B的解释好像不太对。a western Greek alphabet被改编,是有earlier in the same century修饰的,所以肯定是a western Greek alphabet先改变的,主句the Etruscan alphabet in turn had been adapted in the previous century是后发生的。他俩不同时,所以不用分词,而且只要分词结构表伴随带了时间词earlier之类的都是错的,因为本身这些词就限定了动作时间不同时。
那这里加了反身代词做Greek字母表的同位语是表示强调嘛??
对啦,adapt的外延与内涵直接选出A