Quantum theory, although of tremendous scientific value, has nevertheless prompted debate among physicists. The debate arose because quantum theory addresses the peculiar properties of minute objects such as photons and electrons. While one type of experiment shows that these objects behave like particles, with well-defined trajectories through space, another demonstrates that, on the contrary, they behave waves, their peaks and troughs producing characteristic "interference" effects. However, scientists have failed to devise an experiment to demonstrate both behaviors simultaneously.
In the 1920s, two alternate interpretations of quantum theory attempted to resolve this apparently contradictory wave-particle duality. Physicist Niels Bohr argued that wave-particle properties are not contradictory, but complementary. Contrary to our intuition that an object continues to exist in some determined form even though we cannot perceive it, he concluded that the physical of a quantum object is actually undetermined before the object is observed via experiment.
Physicist Werner Heisenberg's "uncertainty principle," by contrast, postulated that we cannot precisely determine two complementary properties, such as position and momentum, of a quantum object simultaneously: if we measure an object's position with absolute certainty, then there is an infinite uncertainty in its momentum, and vice versa. He concluded that although we are limited in our ability to measure objects at the atomic and subatomic levels, their position and momentum are nonetheless defined all along.
Which of the following best describes the organization of the passage?
A thesis is introduced and then amended.
Arguments are presented, weighed, and then reconciled.
A problem is described and different interpretations intended to resolve the problem are presented.
Hypotheses are analyzed, their premises are refuted, and alternatives are suggested to replace the hypotheses.
A theory is advanced, opposing evidence is considered, and the theory is abandoned.
此讲解的内容由AI生成,还未经人工审阅,仅供参考。
C. A problem is described and different interpretations intended to resolve the problem are presented 是正确答案。因为这篇文章解释了量子理论在物理学上引发的争论,接着提出了两个不同的解释来解决这个问题,最后对这两个解释作出总结。不符合A、B、D、E选项的说法,所以选择C选项:A problem is described and different interpretations intended to resolve the problem are presented。
所以是三个不同的观点,而不是两个观点和一个答案?
是的。因为文章没有说最后的“测不准原理”就是对的,所以只是给出了三个不同的观点。
登录 或 注册 后可以参加讨论
错选E,abandoned严重不符。整个文章也没有下结论。